hussEyquation
Menu

NBA player comparison

Bill Tosheff vs. George Kaftan

Change players

Career comparison · Regular season

George Kaftan ranks higher in career impact

Bill Tosheff

1951–52 to 1953–54 · 3 seasons

No. 711 Career Impact Rank
72.5667 Career Composite Lower is better

George Kaftan

1950–51 to 1952–53 · 3 seasons

No. 672 Career Impact Rank
69.6800 Career Composite Lower is better

George Kaftan's best-3 average finish (58.5 vs 64.3333) and best-5 average finish (75.7 vs 77) outweigh Bill Tosheff's best-10 advantages after weighting. The Career Composite gap is 2.8867; lower is better. A model-defined difference, not a confidence interval or proof of a basketball advantage.

The career ranking includes unfilled season slots for Bill Tosheff and George Kaftan. The calculation below shows the published replacement rule; it does not predict how a career will finish.

Historical defense is estimated. See source qualifications.
Bill Tosheff: Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimate
George Kaftan: Reconstructed historical estimate

The ranking calculation Average league finish · lower is better

PlayerBest 350% weightBest 530% weightBest 1020% weight
Bill Tosheff64.3377.0086.50
George Kaftan58.5075.7088.60

These three windows determine Career Impact Rank. See the exact calculation →

The seasons behind their rankings

The same ranking years, viewed through their basketball statistics. Descriptive seasonal averages, not additional ranking inputs.

50% Best 3 + 30% Best 5 + 20% Best 10

Numbers show the stat. Bars show league standing. Average season percentile compares each selected year with eligible NBA players in that same season, then averages those standings using the selected weights. It is not a percentile among careers or extra ranking points. Gray bars describe role or workload, not quality.

Green + ▲ Leads marks the better displayed stat, not the percentile. Equal displayed values, missing comparisons and workload rows stay neutral. These row-by-row leads are not extra ranking points or proof of a meaningful basketball difference.

How to read the percentile bars

All bars share a 0–100 scale, with a midpoint at 50. Higher means a higher within-season standing; turnover avoidance reverses the direction so higher means fewer turnovers. The averages do not measure differences in era strength. Raw values are weighted seasonal averages, not pooled career stats.

Each season uses all NBA players with at least 450 minutes and an available statistic. Shooting measures require relevant attempts; lineup estimates require at least 1,000 possessions and an eligible sample. Cohort sizes vary by metric and season. Annual midrank percentiles retain full precision before averaging. Every required season must have both a valid statistic and a valid comparison pool. Impact Rate is a published model score, not a second percentile.

See included seasons and weights

Seasons are selected by published league finish, with the earlier year breaking ties. Best 3, 5 and 10 overlap intentionally. Missing years are never replaced with invented statistics.

Bill Tosheff

  1. 1951–52No. 55 · 24.67%Best 3 · Best 5 · Best 10
  2. 1952–53No. 63 · 24.67%Best 3 · Best 5 · Best 10
  3. 1953–54No. 75 · 24.67%Best 3 · Best 5 · Best 10

George Kaftan

  1. 1951–52No. 33 · 24.67%Best 3 · Best 5 · Best 10
  2. 1950–51No. 41 · 24.67%Best 3 · Best 5 · Best 10

These players do not yet share a complete Best 3 ranking window. A side-by-side statistical profile is unavailable. You can still inspect available observations below; missing years will not be filled.

Regular season only. Missing data are not zero. Every statistic uses the same selected years. Complete shorter windows may be available when the full profile is not.

Uses the selected window. Download social card and Share image use this detailed graphic too.

Select a complete common ranking window and let its source comparisons finish loading to preview a graphic.

Career totals, peak and full comparison table

The comparison in numbers

Ranking and impact

Bill TosheffMeasureGeorge Kaftan
Career Impact RankPeak-weighted regular-season rankLower is better.
Bill Tosheff#711
George Kaftan#672Better result for this measure.
Best 3 average finish50% weightLower is better.
Bill Tosheff64.3
George Kaftan58.5Better result for this measure.
Best 5 average finish30% weightLower is better.
Bill Tosheff77.0
George Kaftan75.7Better result for this measure.
Best 10 average finish20% weightLower is better.
Bill Tosheff86.5Better result for this measure.
George Kaftan88.6
Peak era-centered impactEstimated points per 100 possessions above that season's league average
Bill Tosheff-1.1
George Kaftan+0.5Better result for this measure.
Points above replacementRegular season · fixed -2.0 replacement baseline · higher is better
Bill Tosheff+37 pts
George Kaftan+76 ptsBetter result for this measure.

Career Composite weights average league finishes over the best three, five and ten regular seasons at 50%, 30% and 20%. Lower is better. It is not a cumulative box-score ranking.

Career scoring, passing and playing time

Bill TosheffMeasureGeorge Kaftan
Games
Bill Tosheff203
George Kaftan136
Minutes
Bill Tosheff6,339
George Kaftan2,283
Points per game
Bill Tosheff9.2Better result for this measure.
George Kaftan5.6
Rebounds per game
Bill Tosheff3.0
George Kaftan3.1Better result for this measure.
Assists per game
Bill Tosheff3.3Better result for this measure.
George Kaftan1.4
True shooting
Bill Tosheff39.7%
George Kaftan43.0%Better result for this measure.

Green marks the better result for a directional measure. Playing time describes workload, not quality. Missing data are not zero.

Share

Why they rank this way

George Kaftan's better best-3 and best-5 league finishes outweigh Bill Tosheff's better best-10 finishes after the 50% / 30% / 20% weighting. Peak impact and total career value are separate evidence, not extra points in that formula.

George Kaftan's advantages contribute 3.3067 Composite points, offset by 0.42 in the other direction. The net difference is 2.8867. Displayed values are rounded; the calculation retains full precision.

Regular season only. Impact figures are estimates; small gaps are not exact. Playoffs, awards and titles do not determine the verdict.

The strongest case for each player

The measured case for Bill Tosheff

Best 10 average finish: 86.5, compared with 88.6. Games: 203, compared with 136. PPG: 9.2, compared with 5.6. These are distinct measures, not votes or additional points added to the ranking.

The measured case for George Kaftan

Points-above-replacement rank: #1457, compared with #1636. Peak era-centered impact: +0.5, compared with -1.1. Points above replacement: +76 pts, compared with +37 pts. These are distinct measures, not votes or additional points added to the ranking.

Career Impact RankSee exactly how both rankings are calculatedBill Tosheff72.567 Composite · Lower is better
No. 711 all-time
George Kaftan69.680 Composite · Lower is better
No. 672 all-time

Only the three league-finish windows below determine Career Impact Rank. Career Value and peak impact are separate measures; neither adds points to this calculation. Lower composite scores rank higher.

Bill Tosheff

72.567 Composite · Lower is better · No. 711 all-time

Bill Tosheff's Career Composite windows
Window and finishes usedAverage finish
Lower is better
WeightContribution
Lower is better
Best 3No. 551951–52Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimateNo. 631952–53Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimateNo. 751953–54Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimate64.33350%32.167
Best 5No. 551951–52Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimateNo. 631952–53Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimateNo. 751953–54Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimate2 open slots × No. 9677.00030%23.100
Best 10No. 551951–52Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimateNo. 631952–53Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimateNo. 751953–54Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimate7 open slots × No. 9686.50020%17.300

32.167 + 23.100 + 17.300= 72.567

Open-season rule: every unfilled slot uses No. 96, this player's stored replacement finish.

George Kaftan

69.680 Composite · Lower is better · No. 672 all-time

George Kaftan's Career Composite windows
Window and finishes usedAverage finish
Lower is better
WeightContribution
Lower is better
Best 3No. 331951–52Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimateNo. 411950–51Reconstructed historical estimate1 open slot × No. 101.558.50050%29.250
Best 5No. 331951–52Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimateNo. 411950–51Reconstructed historical estimate3 open slots × No. 101.575.70030%22.710
Best 10No. 331951–52Reconstructed historical estimateIncludes bounded historical defense estimateNo. 411950–51Reconstructed historical estimate8 open slots × No. 101.588.60020%17.720

29.250 + 22.710 + 17.720= 69.680

Open-season rule: every unfilled slot uses No. 101.5, this player's stored replacement finish.

Averages, contributions, and totals are displayed to three decimal places. The ranking calculation keeps full source precision. Read the full method →

Supporting evidence

Individual statistics across the best ten impact seasons

These are each player's averages across up to ten best seasons. Career Impact Rank gives the Best 3, Best 5, and Best 10 average league finishes 50%, 30%, and 20% window weights, giving the most weight to the highest peak. The model accounts for position, role, pace, playing time, and team results. Statistics that were not recorded in earlier eras are left out.

Bill Tosheff: 3 qualifying seasons. George Kaftan: 2 qualifying seasons.

Winning, playoffs, and awards

Basketball context, not inputs to the regular-season impact ranking.

Career team results and honors
Bill TosheffMeasureGeorge Kaftan

Regular-season team context

Final records for teams in the seasons the player represented them. These are team totals, not wins in the games he personally played. A traded season can include more than one team.

Bill Tosheff leads 0; George Kaftan leads 3; 2 tied.

83Team regular-season wins89Leads this measure.
39.7%Team winning percentage44.1%Leads this measure.
050-win team seasons0
060-win team seasons0
2Playoff team seasons3Leads this measure.

Playoff context

Team playoff results count only seasons when the player appeared in a playoff game. These are team achievements, not a measure of individual playoff impact.

Bill Tosheff leads 0; George Kaftan leads 3; 2 tied.

2Playoff appearances2
4Playoff games21Leads this measure.
0Team playoff wins16Leads this measure.
0Finals appearances2Leads this measure.
0Championships0

Awards and honors

Recorded NBA selections and major regular-season honors. A zero means none recorded; unavailable means the field is missing.

Bill Tosheff leads 0; George Kaftan leads 0; 0 tied; 6 unavailable or not comparable.

0All-StarUnavailable
0MVPUnavailable
0All-NBAUnavailable
0All-DefenseUnavailable
0DPOYUnavailable
1Rookie of the YearUnavailable
How these context measures are counted
Team regular-season wins and winning percentage
Wins credited to each listed team's final record in every season the player represented that team. Winning percentage divides those wins by those teams' total games. These do not measure wins personally created by the player.
50- and 60-win team seasons
Listed team-seasons finishing with at least 50 or 60 wins. Shortened seasons are not projected to 82 games.
Team seasons reaching playoffs
Listed team-seasons in which the team qualified for the playoffs.
Playoff appearances and games
Postseasons and games in which the player appeared.
Team playoff wins, Finals and championships
Team results in postseasons when the player appeared. Finals and championships count seasons when he played in the playoffs for the finalist or champion.
Awards
Recorded NBA selections and major regular-season honors. Tied counts remain ties. Missing source fields are not zero.

Source and scope: Basketball Reference, NBA seasons 1950–51 through 2025–26, accessed 2026-10-09.

Career Shape Explorer

How the careers developed

Follow every regular season by calendar year, NBA experience or age. This view describes the path; it does not create another verdict.

View
Align careers by
Bill TosheffGeorge Kaftan◆ Single-season peak

Estimated points per 100 possessions above that season's league average. Zero is average; higher is better.

Some seasons have fewer than 40 games. Select a season to see each player's games and the size of the sample.

Calendar years: both players share the same season scale.

George Kaftan: peak unavailable

Historical defense is estimated. Select a season for its source qualification; an estimate is not a confidence interval.

Axis years are season-ending years: ’82 means 1981–82. The full observed range stays visible. Select a bar, use the season selector, or use keyboard arrow keys for exact values. Empty positions are not zero. Season timeline contains the complete linked evidence.
Explore individual seasons: full statistical profiles

Individual-season deep dive

Explore individual seasons

These are individual seasons selected to illustrate each player's statistical profile. They are not career averages, peak-window averages, or the calculation behind the comparison verdict.

Starts with each player’s best qualifying published season rank, using the latest year to break ties. Change either year without changing the verdict above.

Bill Tosheff

· Loading profile

George Kaftan

· Loading profile

Reading the bars: Actual values come first. Percentiles show standing within a season; higher usually means a higher value. Blue and purple identify the players, while gray describes role or workload.

Exact comparison groups and eligibility

Each measure’s help button also provides its exact population. Impact Rate is a published 0–100 score, not a percentile. Turnover avoidance reverses the direction: higher means fewer turnovers. Percentiles do not measure era strength or add points to the verdict. Missing data are not zero.

Impact Rate
Published model score, not a percentile.
Season Value
Comparison population unavailable.
Offensive lineup impact
Comparison population unavailable.
Defensive lineup impact
Comparison population unavailable.
True shooting
Comparison population unavailable.
Field-goal shooting
Comparison population unavailable.
Three-point shooting
Comparison population unavailable.
Free-throw shooting
Comparison population unavailable.
Free-throw rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Three-point attempt rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Assist rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Turnover avoidance
Comparison population unavailable.
Rebound rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Steal rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Block rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Offensive usage
Comparison population unavailable.
Points per game
Comparison population unavailable.
Rebounds per game
Comparison population unavailable.
Assists per game
Comparison population unavailable.
Minutes per game
Comparison population unavailable.
Games played
Comparison population unavailable.
Total minutes
Comparison population unavailable.

Impact

Impact RatePublished 0–100 score · higher is better
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Season Value
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Offensive lineup impact
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Defensive lineup impact
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Scoring

True shooting
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Passing and possession

Assist rate
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Turnover avoidanceHigher percentile = fewer turnovers
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Rebound rate
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Role and playing time

Offensive usagePossessions finished with shots, free throws or turnovers. Not touches or passing involvement.Role / volume · not a quality score
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Points per gameRole / volume · not a quality score
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Games playedRole / volume · not a quality score
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Total minutesRole / volume · not a quality score
Bill TosheffNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

George KaftanNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Current-season data updates