hussEyquation
Menu

NBA player comparison

Joakim Noah vs. Josh Smith: First 5 seasons

Change players

First 5 seasons · Regular season

Joakim Noah had the stronger first 5 seasons

Average era-centered impact · Higher is better. Joakim Noah: +1.7; Josh Smith: +1.5. Difference: 0.2348 estimated points per 100 possessions above league average. Not a confidence interval.

Historical defense is estimated. See source qualifications.
Joakim Noah: Recorded box inputsIncludes bounded historical defense estimate
Josh Smith: Recorded box inputsIncludes bounded historical defense estimate

The comparison in numbers

Joakim Noah: 2007–08, 2008–09, 2009–10, 2010–11, 2011–12

Josh Smith: 2004–05, 2005–06, 2006–07, 2007–08, 2008–09

Ranking and impact

Joakim NoahMeasureJosh Smith
Average era-centered impactEstimated points per 100 possessions above that season's league average
Joakim Noah+1.7Better result for this measure.
Josh Smith+1.5
Average league finishLower is better.
Joakim Noah67.2Better result for this measure.
Josh Smith75.2
Points above replacementCumulative value in the selected regular seasons
Joakim Noah+638 pts
Josh Smith+853 ptsBetter result for this measure.

These numbers cover only the selected seasons. They are not whole-career totals.

Selected-window scoring, passing and playing time

Joakim NoahMeasureJosh Smith
Games
Joakim Noah330
Josh Smith376
Minutes
Joakim Noah8,918
Josh Smith12,550
Points per game
Joakim Noah8.9
Josh Smith14.0Better result for this measure.
Rebounds per game
Joakim Noah8.6Better result for this measure.
Josh Smith7.4
Assists per game
Joakim Noah1.8
Josh Smith2.6Better result for this measure.
True shooting
Joakim Noah56.6%Better result for this measure.
Josh Smith51.4%

Green marks the better result for a directional measure. Playing time describes workload, not quality. Missing data are not zero.

Share

Why they rank this way

Joakim Noah averaged +1.7, compared with +1.5 for Josh Smith. The first 5 regular seasons after each player's debut are selected. Josh Smith created more total value in the selected seasons.

Regular season only. Impact figures are estimates; small gaps are not exact. Playoffs, awards and titles do not determine the verdict.

The strongest case for each player

The measured case for Joakim Noah

Average league finish: 67.2, compared with 75.2. RPG: 8.6, compared with 7.4. TS%: 56.6%, compared with 51.4%. These are distinct measures, not votes or additional points added to the ranking.

The measured case for Josh Smith

Points above replacement: +853 pts, compared with +638 pts. PPG: 14.0, compared with 8.9. APG: 2.6, compared with 1.8. These are distinct measures, not votes or additional points added to the ranking.

Winning, playoffs, and awards

Basketball context, not inputs to the regular-season impact ranking.

Career team results and honors
Joakim NoahMeasureJosh Smith

Regular-season team context

Final records for teams in the seasons the player represented them. These are team totals, not wins in the games he personally played. A traded season can include more than one team.

Joakim Noah leads 2; Josh Smith leads 2; 1 tied.

554Team regular-season wins593Leads this measure.
53.3%Leads this measure.Team winning percentage48.8%
350-win team seasons3
1Leads this measure.60-win team seasons0
8Playoff team seasons10Leads this measure.

Playoff context

Team playoff results count only seasons when the player appeared in a playoff game. These are team achievements, not a measure of individual playoff impact.

Joakim Noah leads 1; Josh Smith leads 1; 3 tied.

8Playoff appearances8
62Playoff games73Leads this measure.
34Leads this measure.Team playoff wins31
0Finals appearances0
0Championships0

Awards and honors

Recorded NBA selections and major regular-season honors. A zero means none recorded; unavailable means the field is missing.

Joakim Noah leads 4; Josh Smith leads 0; 2 tied.

2Leads this measure.All-Star0
0MVP0
1Leads this measure.All-NBA0
3Leads this measure.All-Defense1
1Leads this measure.DPOY0
0Rookie of the Year0
How these context measures are counted
Team regular-season wins and winning percentage
Wins credited to each listed team's final record in every season the player represented that team. Winning percentage divides those wins by those teams' total games. These do not measure wins personally created by the player.
50- and 60-win team seasons
Listed team-seasons finishing with at least 50 or 60 wins. Shortened seasons are not projected to 82 games.
Team seasons reaching playoffs
Listed team-seasons in which the team qualified for the playoffs.
Playoff appearances and games
Postseasons and games in which the player appeared.
Team playoff wins, Finals and championships
Team results in postseasons when the player appeared. Finals and championships count seasons when he played in the playoffs for the finalist or champion.
Awards
Recorded NBA selections and major regular-season honors. Tied counts remain ties. Missing source fields are not zero.

Source and scope: Basketball Reference, NBA seasons 1950–51 through 2025–26, accessed 2026-10-09.

Selected seasons

Era-centered impact

Season one is aligned with season one. A missing bar means the player did not have a value for that career season.

Joakim NoahJosh Smith

Estimated points per 100 possessions above that season's league average. Zero is average; higher is better.

The full observed range stays visible. Select a bar, use the season selector, or use keyboard arrow keys for exact values. Empty positions are not zero.
Chart values as text

1. Joakim Noah, 2007–08: +0.2 points per 100 possessions. Josh Smith, 2004–05: -0.2 points per 100 possessions

2. Joakim Noah, 2008–09: +1.0 points per 100 possessions. Josh Smith, 2005–06: +0.5 points per 100 possessions

3. Joakim Noah, 2009–10: +1.3 points per 100 possessions. Josh Smith, 2006–07: +2.4 points per 100 possessions

4. Joakim Noah, 2010–11: +2.6 points per 100 possessions. Josh Smith, 2007–08: +3.1 points per 100 possessions

5. Joakim Noah, 2011–12: +3.6 points per 100 possessions. Josh Smith, 2008–09: +1.7 points per 100 possessions

Explore individual seasons: full statistical profiles

Individual-season deep dive

Explore individual seasons

These are individual seasons selected to illustrate each player's statistical profile. They are not career averages, peak-window averages, or the calculation behind the comparison verdict.

Starts with each player’s best qualifying published season rank, using the latest year to break ties. Change either year without changing the verdict above.

Joakim Noah

· Loading profile

Josh Smith

· Loading profile

Reading the bars: Actual values come first. Percentiles show standing within a season; higher usually means a higher value. Blue and purple identify the players, while gray describes role or workload.

Exact comparison groups and eligibility

Each measure’s help button also provides its exact population. Impact Rate is a published 0–100 score, not a percentile. Turnover avoidance reverses the direction: higher means fewer turnovers. Percentiles do not measure era strength or add points to the verdict. Missing data are not zero.

Impact Rate
Published model score, not a percentile.
Season Value
Comparison population unavailable.
Offensive lineup impact
Comparison population unavailable.
Defensive lineup impact
Comparison population unavailable.
True shooting
Comparison population unavailable.
Field-goal shooting
Comparison population unavailable.
Three-point shooting
Comparison population unavailable.
Free-throw shooting
Comparison population unavailable.
Free-throw rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Three-point attempt rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Assist rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Turnover avoidance
Comparison population unavailable.
Rebound rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Steal rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Block rate
Comparison population unavailable.
Offensive usage
Comparison population unavailable.
Points per game
Comparison population unavailable.
Rebounds per game
Comparison population unavailable.
Assists per game
Comparison population unavailable.
Minutes per game
Comparison population unavailable.
Games played
Comparison population unavailable.
Total minutes
Comparison population unavailable.

Impact

Impact RatePublished 0–100 score · higher is better
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Season Value
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Offensive lineup impact
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Defensive lineup impact
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Scoring

True shooting
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Passing and possession

Assist rate
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Turnover avoidanceHigher percentile = fewer turnovers
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Rebound rate
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Role and playing time

Offensive usagePossessions finished with shots, free throws or turnovers. Not touches or passing involvement.Role / volume · not a quality score
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Points per gameRole / volume · not a quality score
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Games playedRole / volume · not a quality score
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Total minutesRole / volume · not a quality score
Joakim NoahNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Josh SmithNo seasonLoading…

Loading same-season percentile…

Current-season data updates